Sunday, January 17, 2010

We need be careful we do not kill Haiti with love

One of the many ways chosen by our government to ease the pain of the Haitian people is the fast-tracking of immigration from that nation. The government intends to give priority to applications by Canadian citizens seeking to sponsor close family members from Haiti. And Haitians temporarily in Canada will be allowed to extend their stay.

It is hard to blame our government for any of this, of course, as I’m convinced its motives are pure. Surely no one would want to deny quick relief to those relatively few Haitians who will qualify for these temporary measures. Yet I can’t deny the unease I feel for the long-term recovery of that Caribbean nation.

Haiti’s problems go back decades before this most recent catastrophe. Some might say that Haiti has not had a stable, fully functioning society with anything close to social justice since the late 1400s when the Tainos ruled the island of Hispaniola that Haiti shares with the Dominican Republic.

Spanish rule was pretty well a disaster for the indigenous Taino population. And, although it is true that during French colonization Haiti was one of the richest countries of the Americas, that society was built on a slave economy with all the brutal reality that suggests. From 1791 to independence in 1804, revolutionary battles took the lives of tens of thousands of Haitians. Historians have estimated the slave rebellion resulted in the death of 100,000 blacks and 24,000 of the 40,000 white colonists. And, in its attempt to retake the colony, France lost more than 50,000 soldiers.

In its 200-year post-independence history, Haiti has suffered 32 coups; the instability of government and society has little equal in the Americas. For the period 1915 to 1934, Haiti lost its independence and was “administered” by the United States.

In 1937, after the U.S. had withdrawn, between 10,000 and 20,000 Haitians living on the border with Dominican Republic were murdered by Dominican dictator Rafael Trujillo. And its been downhill from there.

So what kind of Haiti will there be once the international community has restored some measure of stability there? Will Haiti be much the same as it was in pre-2010 times? It would be a great shame if that happened, but what’s the alternative? After decades of brain-drain to Canada, the United States and elsewhere, can Haiti now sustain itself. And, if it cannot sustain itself, how long will it be before it can?

Every well-educated and talented Haitian who immigrates to Canada is one less Haitian to participate in the rebuilding of that society. Teachers, technicians, trained medical workers, farmers, civil servants and entrepreneurs will all be vital to the reconstruction. And where will they be found?

We need be very careful we do not kill Haiti with our love.

Return to Main page »
© 2009 Russell G. Campbell
All rights reserved.


  1. Has Harper overreacted? Harper is using our already broken down refugee and/or immigration system to make it easier for this country to accept thousands of Haitians who will no doubt enjoy their life here taking full advantage of our welfare, educational, medical, ect systems. Some might surprise us and actually take an affirmative action job offer that could have gone to an unemployed Canadian!

    The Family Reunification Program permits less educated, less skillful and often older more costly immigrants into the country. This program should be terminated since it bestows little, if any value, and has enormous costs.


  2. machiavelli, my post was not in any way intended to be anti-immigration.

    I see Haitian immigration as a "win" for all Canadians, but perhaps a loss for Haiti--that was my point.

    I completely reject your nonsense about "…Haitians who will no doubt enjoy their life here taking full advantage of our welfare, educational, medical, ect systems. Some might surprise us and actually take an affirmative action job offer that could have gone to an unemployed Canadian!"

    Your comment has a decidedly unpleasant slant to it and is not welcome here.

  3. He's entitled to his opinion.

    Blogs cannot be just echo chambers for your own thoughts, not with comment sections...

    Immigration is a touchy issue with Canadians, especially when there has been rampant abuse in the system

  4. If Harper can just temper the urge to help with reason,then canada and Haiti will be good.Think actions through as we go.Id still support some kind of program for our skilled labour force and professionals to teach haitians so they can rebuild their own country more effectively.
    Immigration TO canada takes 2 years going through the system properly with a sponser.That is a fact since ive done it.So it does work.


  5. Hi Russ, very interesting post. I have to agree that destiny of this country has been difficult and the earthquake has certainly the biggest impact on it. The question of immigration policy is very delicate topic. I think that fast-tracking of immigration has been a helpful move from the Canadian side. And certainly Haiti will need all those educated and skilled Haitians who are alive during the very hard period of recovery. So the task of government is to create conditions that would motivate them to stay.

    Good luck,